Can I Recover Out-of-Pocket Repair Expenses After a Car Accident?

If another driver was at fault, Michigan law may let you recover up to $3,000 for the vehicle damage you paid for out of pocket. Michigan Auto Law handles the whole claim for you, at no cost to you.

Driver reviewing a car repair bill after an accident, eligible for a Michigan mini tort claim up to $3,000

The estimate said one thing. Then came the parts that were not covered, the gap your insurance left, and the money that came straight out of your own account. You paid it because you wanted your car fixed. That does not mean the money had to stay gone.

You Paid the Repair Bill Someone Else Caused. Why Are You Out of Pocket?

Most drivers think the repair estimate is the whole story. Then the final bill lands higher than the payout, or your deductible eats the first several hundred dollars, and suddenly you are covering costs for damage you did not cause. It feels like the price of moving on. It is not. When another driver caused the crash, a chunk of those out-of-pocket vehicle damage costs may be money you are owed, and most people never find out.

Out-of-pocket auto repair costs from a crash someone else caused, recoverable through a mini tort claim

How Out-of-Pocket Repair Recovery Works in Michigan

Michigan’s mini-tort law lets a not-at-fault driver recover up to $3,000 in vehicle damage directly from the at-fault driver’s insurance company. That can cover the deductible you already paid and other qualifying out-of-pocket repair costs, up to the limit. To qualify, you need to be the registered owner and named insured on the vehicle, you cannot be the one at fault, and the driver who hit you needs to have had insurance. This is a property damage claim only. It is separate from any injury claim and does not require you to have been hurt.

What this claim covers:

This claim is built to recover out-of-pocket vehicle damage costs, including the deductible you already paid. It is a focused property damage claim, not an injury case, and it does not require you to file another claim with your insurance company.

Not-at-fault driver using Michigan's mini tort law to recover a deductible and repair expenses

How Repair Cost Recovery Works with Michigan Auto Law

One Simple Form. Then We Do the Rest.

There is nothing complicated to figure out and no bill to chase on your own. You fill out one short form online with the basics, and Michigan Auto Law takes it from there.

The steps:

  1. You submit one simple form with the basics of your accident.
  2. We contact the at-fault driver’s insurance company and send the demand.
  3. We handle all the paperwork and the back and forth, and keep you updated by email.
  4. We confirm your payment and arrange for your check to reach you.

There is no attorney fee for this service. What is free is our handling of the claim. The recovery itself comes from the at-fault driver’s insurer.

No Catch. Here's Why We Do This.

When you have already paid out of pocket once, a free service can sound like it must come with a second cost buried somewhere. It does not. There is no attorney fee, no obligation, and the money you recover comes from the at-fault driver’s insurer, not from us and not from your own insurer. We handle this because helping a Michigan driver get back money they are owed is the kind of thing that puts People Over Everything into practice. And if it turns out you were hurt in the accident too, you will already be talking to the firm Michigan trusts most for that.

Our firm is 100% specialized in auto law. Insurance companies use claims software that factors in your law firm when calculating what to offer, and there is a reason insurance companies pay Michigan Auto Law clients up to 4x more. With more million-dollar motor vehicle results in Michigan over the last 20 years than any other law firm, you are handing your claim to a firm that takes it seriously.

Over 3,500 Five-Star Reviews. That's Not Marketing. That's People Telling the Truth.

Michigan Auto Law has earned more than 3,500 five-star reviews from real clients. Awards are nice. This matters more.

  • Over 3,500 Five-Star Reviews. That's Not Marketing. That's People Telling the Truth.


    “Honestly great place and great people to work with. I had trouble filing for a mini tort claim due to life factors, but their process made it simple and quick just a bit of information through their website and that's it nothing else made the process a blessing to me. Especially as someone working midnights. I was able to do it through my phone within a few minutes. I will be recommending their services to everyone I know and will be coming back in the future for any incidents. Also their constant responses and keeping me updated throughout the entire process and if there were any issues they contacted me and let me know. Genuinely a great place to come to if you have any trouble.

    Haidar Fakhruldin


  • Over 3,500 Five-Star Reviews. That's Not Marketing. That's People Telling the Truth.


    “So glad I heard Michigan Auto Law’s commercial in the radio regarding recovery of my deductible for an auto accident that wasn’t my fault. No fees, no strings. Easy process, kept me informed until I received my check. Thank you so much!

    Denise


  • Over 3,500 Five-Star Reviews. That's Not Marketing. That's People Telling the Truth.


    “Absolute amazing experience! Just had to provide some basic information and they handled everything! I received a check very quickly. I couldn’t be happier! Couldn’t recommend them enough! Thank you!!!!!!!

    Jon Doe


  • Over 3,500 Five-Star Reviews. That's Not Marketing. That's People Telling the Truth.


    “After my insurance company gave up trying to recover my deductible from the at fault driver's insurance I figured I would never see that money. After a quick internet search I came across Michigan Auto Law's mini-tort service. With just a quick conversation on the phone, a short while later a check for my deductible showed up in mailbox! Thanks Michigan Auto Law!!!!

    Matt Merkel


Common Questions About Recovering Out-of-Pocket Repair Costs

Often, yes. Michigan’s property damage law lets a not-at-fault driver pursue up to $3,000 in vehicle damage from the at-fault driver’s insurer. If you paid a deductible or covered a gap between the estimate and the final repair bill, those out-of-pocket costs may fall within what you can claim back. Eligibility depends on fault, ownership, and the other driver having insurance.

This is a vehicle damage claim, so it centers on the costs of repairing your car, including the deductible you paid. The total recovery is capped at $3,000. Submit the form and we will review the specific expenses tied to your accident and tell you what is eligible.

No. This is a vehicle damage claim only. It exists separately from any injury claim, and you do not need to have been hurt to pursue the money you paid for repairs.

You may still be able to recover those costs. Having already paid does not automatically close the door. Submit the form and we will review what you are eligible to claim back.

This is a property damage claim made against the at-fault driver’s insurance, not a claim against your own policy. If you have questions about your specific coverage, we can talk through it during your free claim review.

Michigan law gives you a limited window to protect your rights, and it closes faster than most people realize. The clock starts on the date of your accident. If your crash happened recently, do not assume you are out of options. Start your claim and let us check.

It's Your Money. We'll Help You Get It. For Free.

One simple form starts everything, and there is no fee for our service. Your window for claiming the money you’re owed is limited, so it is worth checking now.